Exercise Price (AKA Strike Price)

What is Exercise Price?

The exercise price, also known as the strike price, is the predetermined price at which the holder of an option can buy or sell the underlying security when exercising the option. In the context of business and startups, the exercise price most commonly refers to the price at which employees, executives, advisors, or investors can purchase shares of company stock through stock options. This price is typically set when the options are granted and remains fixed throughout the option's life, regardless of changes in the market value of the company's shares.

For startups especially, the exercise price plays a crucial role in equity compensation strategies, serving as a powerful tool for attracting and retaining talent, aligning incentives, and conserving cash during early growth stages.

The exercise price is typically set at or near the fair market value of the company's common stock at the time the options are granted. Understanding the nuances of exercise price determination and its implications is essential for both companies issuing options and individuals receiving them.

Types of Exercise Prices

Different business scenarios involve various types of exercise prices, each with unique characteristics and applications:

Employee Stock Option (ESO) Exercise Price: This is the predetermined price at which employees can purchase company shares. For startups, ESO exercise prices are typically set at the fair market value of the company's common stock at the time of grant, as determined by an IRS 409A valuation.
Investor Option Exercise Price: In financing rounds, investors may receive options or warrants with exercise prices tied to their investment terms. These are often set at a premium to the current valuation to provide additional upside potential.
Convertible Note Conversion Price: While not technically an exercise price, the conversion price in convertible notes functions similarly by determining the price at which debt converts to equity.
Anti-dilution Adjustment Exercise Price: Some option agreements include provisions that adjust the exercise price downward if the company issues new shares at a lower price, protecting option holders from dilution.

In each case, the exercise price establishes the threshold above which the option holder stands to profit from exercising their options, creating an important financial incentive structure within the business.

Determining Fair Market Value for Exercise Price

Setting an appropriate exercise price is critical for compliance, accounting, and tax purposes. Here's how companies typically approach this process:

For private companies, particularly startups, determining fair market value requires formal valuation procedures:

409A Valuations: Named after the relevant section of the Internal Revenue Code, these independent appraisals establish the fair market value of common stock.
Board Approval: The company's board of directors must formally approve the exercise price, typically following the recommendation of a 409A valuation.
Regular Reassessment: As a company grows and achieves milestones, the fair market value and corresponding exercise price for new option grants will typically increase. Many startups update their 409A valuations every 12 months or after significant financial events.
Valuation Methodologies: Several approaches may be used to determine fair market value:
1. Market approach (comparing to similar public companies, but at a discount for private companies)
2. Income approach (based on discounted cash flow projections)
3. Asset approach (based on the value of underlying assets)
4. Option pricing model (accounting for various exit scenarios)

Setting the exercise price too low can result in tax penalties for option recipients under Section 409A, while setting it too high reduces the incentive value of the options. Finding the appropriate balance requires careful consideration of both compliance requirements and strategic human capital objectives.

Tax Implications of Exercise Price

The exercise price significantly impacts the tax treatment of stock options for both companies and option holders, with different consequences based on option type and exercise timing:

For Companies:

Companies generally receive tax deductions when non-qualified stock options (NSOs) are exercised, equal to the amount of ordinary income recognized by the option holder.
For Incentive Stock Options (ISOs), companies typically do not receive tax deductions unless the employee sells the shares before meeting statutory holding requirements.
The spread between exercise price and fair market value may affect the company's financial statements through accounting expenses under ASC 718 (formerly FAS 123R).

For Option Holders:

NSOs: The difference between the fair market value and the exercise price at exercise is treated as ordinary income and subject to income tax and employment taxes.
ISOs: No regular income tax is due at exercise (though the spread may trigger Alternative Minimum Tax). If holding requirements are met (at least 1 year after exercise and 2 years after grant), gains are taxed at preferential long-term capital gains rates.
Early Exercise Provisions: Some option plans allow exercise before vesting, potentially reducing tax liability if the exercise price is close to the current fair market value.

The tax efficiency gap between the exercise price and fair market value creates an important consideration in the timing of option exercises. Y Combinator and other startup accelerators often advise founders and early employees to exercise options early when the spread is minimal to optimize tax outcomes.

Sign up for our free weekly AllBusiness.com newsletter HERE.

Exercise Price in Exit Scenarios

The relationship between exercise price and ultimate share value becomes particularly significant during company exit events:

IPO Scenarios: When a company goes public, like Airbnb or Shopify, options with low exercise prices can generate substantial wealth for employees. The spread between the IPO price and the exercise price represents the pre-tax gain for option holders.
Acquisition Events: In M&A transactions, some or all unvested options are often either accelerated or converted to acquirer stock options. The exercise price factors into the conversion calculations and ultimate value delivered to option holders.
Secondary Markets: Prior to exit, employees at later-stage startups might have opportunities to sell vested shares on secondary markets. The profit potential depends directly on the gap between current valuation and original exercise price.
Down-Round Considerations: If a company raises funding at a lower valuation than previous rounds, underwater options (where exercise price exceeds current fair market value) may require repricing or refreshing to maintain their incentive value.

For founders and companies, understanding how exercise prices translate into real value during various exit scenarios helps inform equity strategy decisions. For employees and investors, modeling potential outcomes based on different exit valuations and timelines provides a crucial perspective on option value.

Exercise Price Management Strategies

Companies employ various strategies to optimize the motivational and retention benefits of exercise prices while balancing financial and compliance considerations:

Periodic Option Refreshes: As companies grow and stock prices increase, early employees may hold options with very low exercise prices relative to current value. New option grants at updated exercise prices can create ongoing incentives.
Option Repricing: During market downturns or after significant valuation decreases, companies may reprice underwater options to restore their incentive value, though this requires careful handling of accounting and shareholder approval issues.
Evergreen Reserve: Many startups maintain an "evergreen" provision in their option plans, automatically replenishing the option pool annually, ensuring availability of options at current exercise prices for new and existing employees.
Exercise Price Acceleration Triggers: Option agreements often include provisions that modify exercise terms upon specific events such as change of control or termination, potentially creating significant value for option holders.

For startups navigating rapid growth, thoughtfully designed exercise price strategies can significantly impact talent acquisition and retention. For established companies, managing a portfolio of options with varying exercise prices requires systematic processes to ensure compliance and effectiveness.

Summary of Exercise Price

The exercise price represents an important element of equity compensation in the business world, particularly for startups and growth-stage companies. By establishing the threshold at which option holders can convert their rights into actual ownership, the exercise price creates a direct link between company performance and individual financial outcomes. This alignment of interests serves as a powerful mechanism for attracting talent, incentivizing performance, and rewarding long-term commitment, especially in resource-constrained environments where competitive cash compensation may not be feasible.

Beyond its incentive function, the exercise price carries significant legal, tax, and accounting implications that require careful management. Companies must navigate complex regulatory requirements in setting and adjusting exercise prices, while individuals receiving options need to understand how exercise price decisions affect their potential financial outcomes and tax obligations. As companies evolve from early-stage startups to mature businesses, effective exercise price strategies must adapt to changing circumstances while maintaining compliance and maximizing motivational impact.

Definition of Exercise Price (AKA Strike Price)