it comes to exemplifying poor leadership tactics, here’s one situation that
took place at a recent company retreat. The purpose of this retreat was for the
partners to discuss the corporate vision, new ideas, and growth strategies as
well as year-end goals. It was an opportunity for all of them to get together,
removed from the daily stresses of the office. This year’s two-day retreat was
at a resort built around a majestic 30-square-mile lake.
first day and a half consisted of meetings, outings, and exercises, all of
which were going well. Ken, the managing partner who helped coordinate the
event, was pleased to see that people were enjoying themselves and benefiting
from the experience. That afternoon, he was on his way to a small,
invitation-only breakout group with several of the senior partners in the firm.
meeting was going smoothly, given the diversity and dynamics of the group. Ken
was doing a great job facilitating the conversation and moving from one topic
to the next, all of which had been approved by the senior partners and placed
on the agenda prior to this afternoon event—all except one person. It seemed
that Buck, the founder of the firm, a gray-haired, well-respected, sharp
elderly gentleman, never saw the e-mail that contained the agenda.
Buck is no longer involved in the day-to-day operation of the firm, something
on the agenda not only caught his eye but stirred up quite a strong reaction in
him. Even though Buck had been carefully directed by Ken to be more of an
observer or facilitator, Buck delivered an edgy opinion on this particular
topic. It was a line item listed in the meeting’s agenda that dealt with new
business development initiatives. Specifically, the firm was considering hiring
an outside marketing firm to assist with their public relations and advertising
campaign. “After all these years of sustained double-digit growth, you
think we now need to go out and hire someone to do what we’ve always done
naturally and quite successfully on our own?” asked Buck. “I remember
about 10 years ago, we retained the services of a PR firm with very poor
results. Since when are we no longer competent enough to handle this
Buck shared his thoughts on the matter, the conversation just stopped. No more
open forum. No more safe, open sharing, no more flowing dialogue. An issue
that, less than 10 minutes ago, had full buy in and consensus from the team
regarding the direction to go had now gone full circle, right back to the
beginning. It was as if a new topic had just been introduced, which had no
current buy in or solution. No one said a word until Ken redirected the
conversation to the next item on the agenda.
A possibility or an idea from the boss opens up further
conversation. An expectation shuts it down.
a fact that if you’re a boss, manager, or executive responsible for managing
people, you are their superior. And, therefore, you have a certain degree of
influence over how your staff feels about certain subjects. Buck didn’t make
any decisions. He basically said, “This isn’t the way it used to be. Why is
it different now? Agree with me or experience my wrath.”
and executives have the power to shut down a conversation or open up a
dialogue. Quite often, they don’t realize how much of an influence they have
over their staff and how influential they can be without even trying. When a
manager takes a strong stand or position and makes a statement like, “Here’s
the solution” or “Here’s how it is,” it removes any opportunity for others to
contribute a different and potentially better idea.
a difference between sharing an opinion or idea and sharing an expectation.
It’s one thing if the manager or boss shares an opinion that allows the
dialogue and flow of the conversation to continue moving in a positive,
collaborative direction. It’s entirely different when the manager shares an
expectation with a strong agenda or ultimatum behind it. An opinion or idea
from the boss opens up further conversation. An expectation shuts it down.
could have kept the collective conversation moving forward with an approach
like this. “Here’s one thought that I want to put on the table. It still has
some wet paint on it and needs some further development. I would love to hear
your responses and how you feel about it so that we can incorporate everyone’s
ideas and create something even better.”
With an approach like this, it is likely
that managers will get a response that encourages unfiltered collaboration and