DePaul University in Chicago has denied tenure to Norman
Finkelstein, a Jewish professor of Political Science whose scholarship
has been critical of Jews and the State of Israel. Even though
recommended by his department and his College, the Board of Promotion
and Tenure as well as DePaul's President
recommended against
Finkelstein's tenure after Harvard Law Professor Alan Dershowitz
began making complaints. Finkelstein's official website traces his
tenure decision through articles in The Chicago Sun-Times (June 9,
2007), The Chronicle of Higher Education (June 8, 2007), The Chicago
Tribune (June 10, 2007), The Washington Post (June 10, 2007), and
numerous other sources, as well as examples of Finkelstein's
scholarship. Although DePaul has put him on leave for his last year,
Finkelstein plans on teaching his last year even if it means going to
jail. Student support for Finkelstein has been strong (see www.
defendcriticalthinking.org) and DePaul students, faculty and alumni are
conducting a sit-in to protest the denial of tenure, even though the
administration has threatened the students with expulsion and threatened
faculty and alumni with arrest (see http://www.finkelgate. corn). The
Chronicle of Higher Education of September 5, 2007 concludes this story
by reporting that Finkelstein and the university reached a settlement
and that Finkelstein has resigned.
Robert Jensen's "What the Finkelstein Tenure Fight Tells
Us About the State of Academia" (www.counterpunch. org, May 27,
2007) both reviews the tenure case and suggests what it means for
"the larger project of real academic freedom and
responsibility."
Ethnic Studies Professor Ward Churchill at The University of
Colorado was fired from his tenured position. Although Churchill was
found guilty by a faculty panel at UC of repeated and intentional
academic misconduct, the AAUP chapter of UC has written, "the
investigation now is widely perceived to be a pretext for firing
Churchill when the real reason for dismissal is his politics." For
a fuller version of this story, see www. insidehighered.com, July 25,
2007 and www.defendcriticalthinking.org.