The cruise industry is on a war footing. That means its deploying more ships to places you can drive to. And its sharpening the pricing pencil, again. In fact, it's continuing an approach that's been working for it reasonably well since 9/11.
Cruise shipping often seems to defy economic
Last month, CLIA executive director Bob Sharak told delegates at the Seatrade Cruise Shipping Convention in Miami Beach that the 13 new ships introduced in 2002 were "a significant capacity increase in an uncertain market environment." Sharak made his comments during the annual convention's State of the Industry panel presentation, which included executives from Carnival Corp., Norwegian Cruise Line, Royal Caribbean, Crystal Cruises and Cunard. Sharak told cruise lines that by "maintaining current occupancy levels, we will have the opportunity to welcome 1 million more guests onboard in 2003--a potential of 9.6 million passengers worldwide, including 8.3 million from North America. Now it's up to us to make that happen."
THE PRICE IS RIGHT
But to make it happen, cruise lines will probably have to continue the trend of aggressively pricing cruise vacations and positioning ships in drive and cruise or "homeland" cruising markets. "We're giving away a phenomenal value at ridiculous prices," said panelist Bob Dickinson, president, Carnival Cruise Lines. "We're doing a poor job of demonstrating the value of cruising. A similar vacation on land would cost two to three times as much."
What's a phenomenal value? How about staying seven days at a luxury resort and paying less than $100 a day for your accommodations and meals. That's what it will cost per person on a seven-day cruise from New York to Florida and the Bahamas on the brand new Norwegian Dawn.
TAKING THE AIR OUT OF CRUISING
An to entice new cruisers, prices could drop even further. "The challenge now to grow cruising is to continue to lower the price point; there's a certain point at which the consumer will jump into the market," said Colin Veitch, NCL's CEO.
"We've broadened our base through a domestic cruising push," said Richard Fain, chairman of Royal Caribbean Cruises Ltd.
OF ORDERS AND YARDS
Orders have slowed considerably since 9-11. The current orderbook, while substantial with a value of about $10 billion (see accompanying table), is about half of what it was two years ago. Cruise lines will add 14 new ships in 2003.
"There's an awful lot of capacity that we'll have to digest," said Carnival Corp.'s vice chairman Howard Frank. "You'll see orders but not at the same levels we've seen in the past. These orders will have to reflect our business model. We're going through a very difficult period right now," said Carnival's Frank.
"Long term, we'll need more ships," said Veitch. However, he said that shipyards that currently specialize in cruise ship building are going to have to decide whether they want to stay in the business long term. This could spell tougher competition not only for cruise ship orders, but also for cruise ferry orders as shipyards look to keep their skilled workers and production facilities busy.
As of Feb. 28, based on the number of lower berths, Fincantieri held a 46% market share of the order book, Chantiers de l'Atlantique 15%, Kvaerner Masa Yards 13%, Mitsubishi 9%, Meyer Werft 7% and all others 10%. Only Fincantieri has orders extending beyond 2004.
Kvaerner Masa Yards believes long-term demand for cruise ships will be 1 million gross tons per year and the growth of the fleet about 8%. "We'd like to build one ship per year," Veitch said. "We're currently building one at Lloyd Werft (parts of the first Project America ship started at Northrop Grumman Ship Systems Ingalls Operations, Pascagoula, Miss. Veitch said NCL has also acquired "about 400 containers of parts and equipment for the second Project America ship, though no contract has yet been signed."
The first ship will begin sailing seven-day cruises in Hawaii starting in 2004. He said 3,000 U.S. maritime jobs would be created as a result of the project.
THE MOTHER OF ALL BOATS
Next year also marks the anticipated debut of Cunard Line's Queen Mary 2, which was recently floated out from its building dock to a finishing basin at the Alstom Chantiers de l'Atlantique shipyard in Saint Nazaire, France (see this month's Update section). The float out marks the final stages of construction of the $800-million liner prior to its maiden voyage on Jan. 12, 2004.
When the QM2 enters service, it will carry with it a list of superlatives--the longest, tallest, widest and most expensive passenger liner ever built. QM2 guest will be able to do almost anything they can imagine, from tantalizing their temporals with the world's first planetarium at sea to titillating their taste buds with the largest wine collection at sea.
In its inaugural year, QM2 will make 15 transatlantic crossings.
TAKING STOCK
Better days are ahead for cruise lines, according to Gary Cooper, an analyst for Banc of America Securities LLC. In a research report released Mar. 19, he raised the investment ratings on shares of Royal Caribbean and Carnival Corp. Shares of Royal Caribbean were raised from "sell" to "neutral" and shares of Carnival Corp. were raised from "neutral" to "buy" The reason for the upgrade is that the "cruise industry bookings and prices have been weak due to the uncertainty resulting from the situation in Iraq. We expect prices and bookings to rebound following the resolution of tensions in Iraq." Cooper also thinks that the end of the conflict will lead to lower fuel prices.
While the waters could be a bit rough for cruise lines for the remainder of 2003, on the whole, they are still optimistic about the industry's long-term growth prospects.
Carnival Corp. vice chairman Frank told delegates at Seatrade Cruisse Shipping, "If the situation in Iraq is resolved quickly, we could still have a strong third and fourth quarters."
Carnival chairman and CEO Micky Arison echoed those sentiments in announcing his company's results for the first quarter of 2003. "Although in the short term bookings have been impacted by [the Iraq conflict], we believe that the fundamental long-term drivers of the cruise industry's growth, such as favorable demographics and low penetration of the vacation market, remain intact. It is primarily because of these factors that we have entered into our proposed combination with P&O Princess Cruises plc. Now that we are within sight of the completion of this transaction, we are particularly excited about the future prospects for the combined group and believe that our 16-month effort to combine with P&O Princess will bring enhanced value and opportunity to the shareholders and employees of both companies." Time will tell.
CRUISE SHIPS ON ORDER
(as of 2/26/03)
LINE VESSEL SHIPYARD GT
000s
2003
Aida AIDaura Aker MTW 42
Carnival Carnival Glory Fincantieri 110
Costa Costa Mediterranea Kvaerner Masa 105
Costa Costa Fortuna Fincantieri 105
Crystal Crystal Serenity Ch. de l'Atlantique 68
Cunard Queen Mary 2 Ch. de l'Atlantique 150
HAL Oosterdam Fincantieri 85
Mediterranean Shipping MSC Lyrica Ch. de l'Atlantique 60
Princess Island Princess Ch. de l'Atlantique 88
Radisson Seven Seas Seven Seas Voyager T. Mariotti 50
Royal Caribbean Mariner of the Seas Kvaerner Masa 140
Royal Caribbean Serenade of the Seas Meyer Werft 88
2004
Birka Line N/A Aker Finnyards 33
Carnival Carnival Miracle Kvaerner Nasa 86
Carnival Carnival Valor Fincantieri 110
Costa Costa Magica Fincantieri 105
HAL Westerdam Fincantieri 85
Mediterranean Shipping MSC Opera Ch. de l'Attantique 60
NCL (ex Project America) Lloydwerft 81
Princess Caribbean Princess Fincantieri 116
Princess Sapphire Princess Mitsubishi 113
Princess Diamond Princess Mitsubishi 113
Royal Caribbean Jewel of the Seas Meyer Werft 88
2005
Cunard N/A Fincantieri 85
HAL N/A Fincantieri 85
2006
Carnival N/A Fincantieri 110
HAL N/A Fincantieri 85
LINE Lower Price Delivery
Berths ($ Mil.)
2003
Aida 1,300 200 April
Carnival 2,114 510 June
Costa 2,720 350 May
Costa 2,720 400 Nov.
Crystal 1,080 350 June
Cunard 2,620 780 Dec
HAL 1,848 410 June
Mediterranean Shipping 1,600 250 2nd Q
Princess 1,950 360 June
Radisson Seven Seas 700 215 Feb
Royal Caribbean 3,100 520 Oct
Royal Caribbean 2,000 350 4th Q
2004
Birka Line 1,800 154 3rd Q
Carnival 2,124 375 March
Carnival 3,000 510 Nov
Costa 2,720 460 Nov
HAL 1,848 410 May
Mediterranean Shipping 1,600 270 Spring
NCL 2,100 350 N/A
Princess 3,100 460 April
Princess 2,670 450 May
Princess 2,670 450 Feb
Royal Caribbean 2,000 350 June
2005
Cunard 1,968 410 Feb
HAL 1,848 410 Nov
2006
Carnival 2,974 460 Jan
HAL 1,848 390 June
Source: Marine Log, company reports
World cruise ship fleet capacity, based on lower berths, including ships
on order
Source: Kvaerner Masa Yards
Carnival 29%
P&O Princess 13%
Royal Carribean 20%
Star 10%
Others 27%
Total 323 ships, 350 000 beds