Small Business Resources, Business Advice and Forms from AllBusiness.com
 

Sex and Reason.

By Sandler, Ralph
Publication: Southern Economic Journal
Date: Friday, April 1 1994

In this ambitious book, Judge Richard Posner presents an economic theory of sexuality that attempts to explain both the practice of sex and its regulation. Given the pressure on our legal system to address sexual issues raised by the AIDS epidemic, homosexual rights, sexual harassment in the workplace

and public funding of erotic art, among others, this work is very timely. Because of the author's stature and his seminal work in law and economics, it is likely to be very influential.

Posner's approach is to conduct his analysis of sex as though it were a morally neutral subject. For example, the public regulation of food or traffic safety, unlike sexual activity, are issues of public concern but are not subjects normally "charged with moral significance." Its economic impact can be examined with scientific detachment. The author proposes to examine sexual activity and its regulation by applying the same economic model of rational behavior typically reserved for more traditional market and non-market activities. Some may wonder how sex can be viewed as rational. While the sex drive itself is viewed as a biological factor that is given, the decision to engage in particular sex acts are thought to be a matter of rational choice where individuals respond to incentives.

This book has two major themes. First, that variation in sexual practice across societies and over time can be explained by a small number of variables. The primary variables are urbanization, income, the sex ratio (the ratio of males to available females), scientific advances in the control of fertility, and above all, the changing occupational role of women. Posner uses these variables to explain society's behavior and attitudes about subjects as diverse as abortion, illegitimacy, homosexual behavior, prostitution, polygamy, infanticide, rape and pornography.

A key factor in Posner's analysis in explaining the evolution of sexual morality from ancient Greece to the modern era, along with the changing occupational role of women, is the trend to companionate marriage. This dominate form of marriage in the west today can be explained as one in which,

. . . the husband and wife are best friends, social and emotional intimates, close companions. The older form of marriage, noncompanionate marriage, is marriage in which the husband provides the wife with occasional insemination and financial support in exchange for her pledge of sexual fidelity, but there is no expectation of an intimate bond.

In addition, make sure to read these articles:

  • Educational assortative mating across marriage...
  • HEADNOTE EDUCATIONAL ASSORTATIVE MATING ACROSS MARRIAGE MARKETS: NOW HISPANIC WHITES IN THE UNITED STATES* HEADNOTE Whether local marriage market conditions shape marriage behavior is a ......
  • Educational attainment and the transition to first...
  • HEADNOTE EDUCATIONAL ATTAINMENT AND THE TRANSITION TO FIRST MARRIAGE AMONG JAPANESE WOMEN* HEADNOTE I use data from a large nationally representative survey to examine the ......
  • Divorce and female labor force participation:...
  • Introduction Important measures of the economic status of women in the United States include the divorce rate, the labor force participation rate, the fertility rate, ......
  • Think Tank - March 18, 2003
  • Most people thought the Financial Interest and Syndication Rules had a stake driven through their hearts in 1992 when a three-judge panel in Chicago led ......
  • MICROSOFT WANTS "COMMON SENSE" SETTLEMENT.
  • Microsoft advised the Department of Justice that any breakup of its business would be fatal, but indicated that it would accept reasonable restrictions on its ......
  • Debating Surveillance
  • In the latest episode in the contentious debate over the National security Agency's (NSA) domestic surveillance program, legal experts speaking before Congress offered dramatically different ......
  • IN ORDER To HAVE COMPLETE DISCRETION AS TO...
  • Herzberger v. Prudential Insurance Company of America, 205 F.3d 327 (United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit--February 23, 2000) Much of the Employee ......
  • Immigration appeals swell federal dockets
  • An increasing number of immigration cases are being litigated at the circuit level - and many immigration lawyers may be ill- prepared for the challenges....
  • Assessing an interdisciplinary approach to freedom...
  • Bunker, M. D. (2001). Critiquing free speech: First Amendment theory and the challenge of interdisciplinarity. Mahawah, NJ: Erlbaum. 184 pages. In recent years, freedom of ......
  • Microsoft Verdict -- A Win Win Settlement?
  • U.S. District Judge Thomas Penfield Jackson, the presiding federal judge in the Microsoft antitrust case, has extended his deadline for a settlement agreement among the ......
  • Microsoft Verdict -- A Win Win Settlement?
  • U.S. District Judge Thomas Penfield Jackson, the presiding federal judge in the Microsoft antitrust case, has extended his deadline for a settlement agreement among the ......
  • Law, democracy, and domination: Law and society...
  • It is an instructive irony that Frank Munger delivered his Presidential Address in Miami Beach. As someone who was there on Memorial Day weekend of ......
  • Thinking about the indeterminate
  • Thinking about the indeterminate Catastrophe, by Richard A. Posner. New York: Oxford University Press, 2004, 322 pp. Judge Richard Posner, a prominent legal scholar and ......
  • Great Expectations
  • HEADNOTE Intelligence as Savior IMAGE PHOTOGRAPH 1 Opposite: Copies of the 9/11 Commission Report sit on display. Above: US President George W. Bush, surrounded by ......
  • Seventh Circuit Adopts New Test for Reasonable...
  • A recent case in the Seventh Circuit dealt with the complex issue of reasonable compensation in a clearheaded way; and it will be interesting to ......