Small Business Resources, Business Advice and Forms from AllBusiness.com
 

Trade policy in developing countries.

By Conway, Patrick
Publication: Southern Economic Journal
Date: Tuesday, January 1 2002

By Edward F. Buffie.

Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, 2001. Pp. vi, 400. $27.95 (paperback).

This is a very interesting and useful text for the "post-Seattle" discussion of trade policies in developing countries. If the protests associated with the World Trade Organization (WTO)

meetings there have taught us anything, it is that a very vocal opposition has emerged to the concept of trade liberalization among developing countries. The dichotomy in debate is stark: The proponents of trade liberalization speak of the static gains from trade and the power of markets in enticing disciplined economic activity, while the opponents decry the profits accruing to the rich at the expense of the poor that this liberalization will facilitate. The beliefs on both sides are passionate and strongly held, but the grounding in economic theory is limited. Professor Buffie has taken on the task of analyzing the theoretical costs and benefits of trade liberalization in this monograph. As he puts it, "It can be said with some assurance that extreme protectionist policies are economically harmful. But the case for free tra de is not airtight, and there is no general theoretical presumption that the market failures common in LDCs (less developed countries) favor an export-oriented rather than an import-substituting trade strategy" (p. 5). He succeeds handsomely in illuminating these questions with a logic embedded in theory. Let me begin with a disclaimer. Buffie and I seem to have a similar way of framing research questions, and thus I am willing to accept a number of maintained hypotheses in his work to which others might object. These include the following:

(i) modeling of economic activity as the outcome of optimizing behavior,

(ii) a presumption that developing countries are characterized to a greater extent than developed countries by certain forms of market failure,

(iii) a presumption that mathematical modeling can be used to represent the economic interactions of individuals in developing countries, and

(iv) the absence of explicit exploitation of developing countries by developed countries in the international marketplace.

If your own beliefs run counter to these, then Buffie's logic--and my review--will leave you dissatisfied.

Buffie sets an ambitious agenda in this monograph. He analyzes a number of specific policy questions and does so within a consistent theoretical framework that is both intertemporal in nature and has sufficient complexity to capture the features he associates with developing countries. As he says, "I am trying to sell not only a particular set of conclusions but also a general approach to the analysis of policy issues" (p. 3).

In addition, make sure to read these articles:

  • Book review: The Travels of a T-Shirt in the...
  • You don't have to be a full-on economic policy wonk to dig this book. I got my copy from InBubbleWrap , and I wasn't ......
  • McCain's Chief Economic Advisor on Outsourcing
  • What can government do to help small businesses flourish in the U.S? Douglas Holtz-Eakin,Sen. John McCain's chief economic advisor, has answers.
  • Sharing A Better Way
  • A recent trip to China, after an absence of seventeen years, let me experience the sheer rate of China's economic boom.
  • Discussion on world economic order.
  • 1 The discussion centered around three questions, i.e., the President's priority towards trade policy, the impact of trade liberalization on American industries and the standard ......
  • The design of trade liberalization.
  • A long-term review of 19 countries yields Policy Prescriptions for successful implementation of liberalization policies It is by now quite commonly accepted that a liberal ......
  • Jagdish Bhagwati, 2002, Free Trade Today.
  • Princeton: Princeton University Press, pp. 144. Jagdish Bhagwati recounts an episode in Seattle in late 1999 during the failed WTO meetings, when he was shepherded ......
  • Domestic manufacturers become active in NAM...
  • A contingent of small- and medium-sized domestic manufacturers that are members of the National Association of Manufacturers are pressing the organization to adopt changes to ......
  • Trade liberalization, exit, and productivity...
  • HEADNOTE This paper empirically investigates the effects of liberalized trade on plant productivity in the case of Chile. Chile presents an interesting setting to study ......
  • Tanzania's Experience with Trade Liberalization.
  • After Tanzania's economy deteriorated during the 1970s and early 1980s, it took a series of bold steps to liberalize trade. How successful have these efforts ......
  • Free Trade under Fire. .
  • By Douglas A. Irwin. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 2002. Pp. xiii, 257. $27.95. The concept of free trade has attracted acclaim and censure throughout ......
presented by