Small Business Resources, Business Advice and Forms from AllBusiness.com
 

Consumer credit risk and pricing.

By Getter, Darryl E.
Publication: Journal of Consumer Affairs
Date: Jun 22 2006 12:00AM 2006

Previous academic studies viewed borrower rejection as a sign of market imperfections in the consumer credit markets, but this view was based upon the assumption that differences in the levels of borrower creditworthiness could not be accurately identified. Today, it is possible to differentiate

between types of borrowers, and riskier borrowers can participate in credit markets if they are willing to pay relatively higher borrowing costs. Hence, a more critical issue concerning the performance of these markets should be whether loan prices correctly reflect the level of borrower credit risk. This paper reexamines consumer participation in credit markets looking specifically at issues related to the pricing of borrowers of different credit risk.

**********

While an extensive academic literature examines the problem of limited household credit access, consumer credit use has increased significantly for almost two decades. During the late 1980s, researchers such as Luckett (1986) and Canner, Fergus, and Luckett (1988) were already discussing the various innovations in consumer credit markets that made it easier for consumers to finance their expenditures with credit. Automated credit scoring, the growth of asset securitization, and more flexible underwriting standards have encouraged greater competition among lenders to supply credit during the 1990s. Several years of robust economic growth have also stimulated the demand for all forms of credit. Although both supply and demand factors have led to rising mortgage, automobile, and revolving debts, substantially more research has been conducted on consumer credit constraints, while surprisingly very little attention has been given to the increase in credit access.

This paper reexamines issues related to consumer credit market participation. Due to the lack of available repayment information, previous empirical studies could not distinguish between high- and low-risk borrowers and treated all rejected borrowers as "credit constrained." Moreover, the conventional wisdom view suggested that borrowers faced credit constraints because lenders did not have enough information to correctly assess credit risk. However, lenders do have information concerning borrower repayment history that can be used to price credit risk. The 1998 and 2001 Surveys of Consumer Finances (SCFs) also now include questions that can distinguish between differences in household credit quality.(1) Therefore, the first objective of this research is to investigate whether high-credit risk households do in fact account for most credit denials. If borrowers who traditionally would have been considered credit constrained are shown to lack creditworthiness based upon their observable loan repayment histories, then these rejections are not indicative of credit market inefficiencies.

In addition, make sure to read these articles:

  • Survey: Asian Banks Seek Right Strategies and...
  • New Survey from The Asian Banker and Fair Isaac Spotlights Need for Better Data and Analytics for Managing Risk, Fraud and Customer Acquisition SHANGHAI, ......
  • First Advantage Completes Purchase of...
  • ST. PETERSBURG, Fla. -- First Advantage Corporation (NASDAQ:FADV), a global risk mitigation and business solutions provider, and Accufacts Pre-Employment Screening, Inc. (OTCBB:APES), an employment ......
  • First Advantage Selects ControlPath...
  • ENGLEWOOD, Colo. -- ControlPath Inc., a leading developer of automated compliance management solutions, announced today that First Advantage Corporation (NASDAQ: FADV), a leading global ......
  • Experian Announces Comprehensive Consumer...
  • Business Editors and High-Tech Writers ORANGE, Calif.--(BUSINESS WIRE)--Feb. 8, 2001 Experian, a leading information solutions company, Thursday announced the structure of its new consumer credit ......
  • OCC Acting Comptroller Urges Banks to Rethink...
  • Acting Comptroller of the Currency Julie L. Williams said in March 21 speech to bankers that retail lending has undergone a dramatic transformation in recent ......
  • Portfolio Defense Standardizes On S-PLUS;...
  • Business Editors/High-Tech Writers SEATTLE--(BUSINESS WIRE)--Feb. 6, 2003 Insightful Corporation (Nasdaq:IFUL), a leading provider of enterprise software solutions for search and analysis of numbers, text, and ......
  • Gain an Insight into the UK Unsecured Consumer...
  • DUBLIN, Ireland -- Research and Markets (http://www.researchandmarkets.com/reports/c39024) has announced the addition of UK Unsecured Consumer Credit 2006 to their offering. UK Unsecured Consumer Credit ......
  • CreditCards.com: Weekly Credit Card Rate Report.
  • NEW YORK -- Rates on low-interest consumer credit cards remained unchanged this week with an average regular annual percentage rate (APR) of 11.66%, according to ......
  • ShoreBank Pacific Spawns First Consumer Credit...
  • Business Editors/Environment Writers PORTLAND, Ore.--(BUSINESS WIRE)--April 5, 2004 ShoreBank Pacific, an FDIC-insured bank committed to the sustainability of industries indigenous to the Pacific Northwest, today ......
  • Financial Insights Evaluates Risk Tools for...
  • FRAMINGHAM, Mass. -- A new report by global independent research and advisory firm Financial Insights describes risk analysis tools and services that can assist ......
  • Fair, Isaac Partners with Kredi Kayit Burosu A.S.
  • Business Editors SAN RAFAEL, Calif., LONDON & ISTANBUL, Turkey--(BUSINESS WIRE)--June 27, 2002--Fair, Isaac and Company, Incorporated (NYSE:FIC), the leading global provider of analytics and decision ......
  • SIGECOM Selects Fair Isaac Telecom...
  • Business Editors/High-Tech Writers SAN RAFAEL, Calif.--(BUSINESS WIRE)--Oct. 17, 2003 Fair Isaac Corporation (NYSE:FIC), the leading provider of analytics and decision technology, today announced that communications ......
  • Multimedia Available: Forty-two Percent of...
  • Business Editors ADVISORY...for Friday (March 5) NOTE TO EDITORS: Multimedia Assets Available With This Story Include Logos, Photos, Text News Releases --(BUSINESS WIRE) Over four ......
  • Multimedia Available: Forty-Six Percent of...
  • Business Editors ADVISORY...for Friday (March 7) NOTE TO EDITORS: Multimedia Assets Available With This Story Include Logos, Photos, Text News Releases --(BUSINESS WIRE) Almost half ......
  • View Profiles of the Top Five Consumer Credit...
  • DUBLIN, Ireland -- Research and Markets (http://www.researchandmarkets.com/reports/c43220) has announced the addition of the new report from Datamonitor "Western European Consumer Credit 2006" to their offering....