The Indian subsidiaries of U.S. cola giants Coca-Cola Inc.
and
Pepsico Inc. filed suits recently in the India's Kerala High Court
challenging a ban by the government of the southern state on
manufacturing and selling soft drinks. The two companies have asked the
Kerala High Court to overturn bans ordered by the state government and
by the state's director of health services. Kerala had announced
the blanket ban--the first by an Indian state--on Aug. 9, a week after
an environmental group alleged that the soft drinks contained harmful
amounts of pesticides. At least half a dozen other large states have
restricted sales by banning drinks made by Coca-Cola and Pepsico in
schools, colleges, hospitals, and some government offices. Meanwhile,
authorities in the state of Karnataka, which borders Kerala, said they
had filed a case against Coca-Cola in a local court after finding high
pesticide levels in the company's beverages in tests conducted by a
private laboratory. The state government filed charges under the
Prevention of Food Adulteration Act 1954, the state's health
minister R. Ashok said. Coke and Pepsi, which control almost the entire
Indian market for soft drinks, have rejected the charges. They say
drinks sold in India are as safe as those sold anywhere in the world.
While Kerala accounts for a negligible part of soft drink sales, the
total ban by state authorities has attracted widespread attention.
Indian industry groups have urged state governments to first conduct
their own safety tests instead of straightaway banning Coke and Pepsi
beverages. They say failure to do so will hurt India's overseas
image as a law-abiding country.