Small Business Resources, Business Advice and Forms from AllBusiness.com

Business Exchange

Although Hearing Approaches, Sensenbrenner Keeps Mum

By:BILL HOLLAND
Publication: Billboard
Date: Saturday, May 12 2001
The House Subcommittee on Courts, the Internet, and Intellectual Property has scheduled a hearing May 17 about music on the Internet, with a focus on digital-music licensing.

While no official witness list has been released, sources close to the subcommittee say that the panel will include Lyle Lovett, speaking as an ASCAP songwriter; executives from MP3.com and Liquid Audio; and Ed Murphy, president/CEO of the National Music Publishers' Assn (NMPA).

The hearing announcement comes after April 23 filings before the Copyright Office from two important players in the digital-music imbroglio, which indicates some movement toward smoother sailing as congressional focus on the issue grows. Both MP3.com and the Recording Industry Assn. of America (RIAA) asked the office for interim rules or a "safe harbor" to allow services to obtain a compulsory license for on-demand streams or limited downloads during the months before the office rules later this year on the types of transmissions to be included and, possibly, a to-be-determined royalty rate.

'A compulsory license guarantees access to users to all copyright work. Instead of individual marketplace license negotiations, the government, after input from the parties affected, sets a royalty fee to be paid to rights holders.

'The request is a turnaround for the RIAA, which earlier had opposed a compulsory license.

'The NMPA and the Songwriters Guild of America, seeking a higher royalty rate through marketplace negotiations, opposed the request in a joint filing.

'The subcommittee hearing on licensing will mark the first time the music industry and E-commerce community will enter the realm of the new boss of the subcommittee's parent Judiciary Committee, Rep. F. James Sensenbrenner, R-Wis., who set the hearing agenda and date. Since taking the reins from Rep. Henry Hyde, R-Ill., in January, he has ruled his committee and his subcommittees with an iron hand.

'Sensenbrenner is "micro-managing from above," says one congressional observer. "Nobody sets their own agenda, nobody decides on witnesses, nobody sneezes without his prior approval. It's causing some disgruntlement."

'The little Sensenbrenner has said publicly this year about the content-side players in the digital-music arena gives little hope to either the RIAA or the performing right societies to which he is an ally. He is the author of 1998 legislation that carved out an exemption for restaurants and mall shops from paying background music royalties to performing right societies (Billboard, Feb. 11, 1995). He held up all copyright legislation in the House for two years until his law was passed, an approach that rankled many of his colleagues.

'Speaking before E-commerce members of the Digital Music Assn. March 28, Sensenbrenner referred to U.S. entertainment companies as "copyright cartels" and lashed out at ASCAP and BMI, saying that the government rules they operate under, which mandate that the organizations must make licenses available for their music, are outdated and unfair. He said, "The Justice Department has basically given them a free pass on this, and I don't think that's right" for licensing in the digital age (Billboard, April 7).

'Sensenbrenner also took a potshot at the RIAA's digital services royalty collection outfit, SoundExchange, characterizing it as possibly an "antitrust violation" to be "looked at" in the future.

'The chairman's views of the concerns of music publishers and recording artists are unknown. "I guess you could call them 'X factors,' " says one music industry insider here. "We will see what we will see."

'Despite the slightly ominous background Sensenbrenner brings from past encounters and statements about segments of the music industry, veteran Hill observers says that the new chairman's approach is not unusual. "Some other committee chairmen work like that, where the top dog calls the shots. I think everybody had gotten used to Hyde's looser style. He'd tell his subcommittee chairmen, 'Hey, do what you feel is best; just keep me in the loop.' But not Sensenbrenner," notes one observer. "You're not going to see subcommittee chairmen taking [passed] bills to the [House] floor. He's the kind of guy who takes every bill to the floor himself. Most folks are getting accustomed to the change. Some aren't."

'Some had thought that the new chairman by now might have unveiled an intellectual property agenda for the session as broad as that of his Senate counterpart, Sen. Orrin G. Hatch, R-Utah, who announced months ago at the beginning of the session that this committee would review a large number of Internet issues and held a hearing last month that looked at Internet music label and music publisher licensing and how artists fare from it (Billboard, April 14).

'But Sensenbrenner continues to hold his plans close to his chest, doling out items one by one. For example, the Courts, the Internet, and Intellectual Property subcommittee, chaired by Rep. Howard Coble, R-N.C., just held its first hearing of the new session May 2, a procedural Copyright Office oversight meeting.

'Sensenbrenner, who was hosting visiting members of Japan's Diet (Parliament), was unavailable to comment


In addition, make sure to read these articles:

  • Congress Recesses Without Vote on Copyright Bill
  • To the disappointment of many in the music industry, Congress recessed for break Friday without any vote on the Copyright Modernization Act, legislation intended to ......
  • Copyright Chief Urges Digital Music Licensing Reform
  • House Subcommittee, Register of Copyrights Marybeth Peters on Thursday spoke out against the way the music publishing industry is set up to license digital music ......
  • Senators: Settle Download Issues Or Face Intervention
  • A U.S. Senate committee took up the issue of digital downloads yesterday (July 11) in a well-publicized hearing attended by rock stars, label executives, and ......
  • Lawmakers, Others Try To Push Royalty Bill Through
  • There is a concerted effort by leading federal lawmakers and record-industry and artists' groups lobbyists to ensure that when the Senate briefly reconvenes in November, ......
  • New Digital Theft Law Ups Monetary Penalties
  • WASHINGTON, D.C.-President Clinton signed into law in December a bill that raises the ante for music pirates and other copyright-infringement violators by increasing statutory monetary ......
  • House Passes Intellectual Property Bill
  • The House of Representatives yesterday (Sept. 21) passed legislation bolstering intellectual property protection. The "Intellectual Property Protection and Courts Improvements Act of 2004," H.R. 3632, ......
  • E-commerce Tops Industry Agendas For 106th Congress
  • WASHINGTON, D.C.‹Although the myriad issues surrounding electronic commerce will be debated by the recording industry and federal lawmakers during the 106th Congress, which convened Jan....
  • Murphy Leaving Nmpa
  • A familiar voice for American publishers and songwriters is retiring.
  • Web Firms Air Wipo Concerns
  • LOS ANGELES‹The tension between companies involved with the digital transmission of music and video content and the Recording Industry Assn. of America (RIAA) has heated ......
  • Riaa Payment For Sensenbrenner Trip Under Scrutiny
  • The Center for Public Integrity, a public-interest group that investigates corruption in government, says the powerful chairman of the House Judiciary Committee may have violated ......
  • Murphy Warns Oz To Modify New Copyright Legislation
  • SYDNEY-Fear about loopholes in impending Australian copyright legislation has led one of the leading figures in U.S. music publishing to urge the country's government to ......
  • Riaa: Amnesty Nets Calls
  • The music industry's amnesty program for illegal downloaders is generating plenty of interest—and yet another lawsuit.
  • Coalition Meets Prime Minister
  • The Malaysian recording artist/industry personnel anti-piracy coalition GMKMM (the movement to save Malaysia's music heritage) has taken the issue of the country's escalating piracy crisis ......
  • Boehlert is new chair of House Science Committee
  • Rep. Sherwood Boehlert (R-N.Y) is the new chairman of the House Science Committee, replacing Rep. F. James Sensenbrenner, Jr. (R-- Wisc.), who now chairs the ......
  • Industry Upbeat About 2004
  • The government-relations arm of the record industry sees 2004 as a year of positive change—if the dice roll right.