Small Business Resources, Business Advice and Forms from AllBusiness.com
 

Nuclear power plant cancellations: sunk costs and utility stock returns.

Nuclear Power Plant Cancellations: Sunk Costs and Utility Stock Returns

Abstract

This study empirically examines the impact of decisions to cancel nuclear power plants on electric utility common stockholders. The reaction of common stock prices to initial announcements of 58

nuclear power plant cancellations covering the period 1974 through 1984 is analyzed. Decisions to cancel nuclear power plants under construction were associated with significant negative excess stock returns. Furthermore, the larger the sunk costs relative to a utility's common equity at the time of the cancellation, the larger the stock price decline, on average. This relationship was more evident as regulators moved toward allocating relatively greater proportions of the sunk costs to investors.

Introduction

In May 1982, Duke Power announced that it was canceling its Cherokee nuclear power plant. Duke Power had invested over $633 million in the partially completed plant. This sunk cost figure represented over 30 percent of Duke's precancellation net worth. Cincinnati Gas and Electric, with two other electric utilities (American Electric Power and Dayton Power and Light), announced the cancellation of the Zimmer nuclear power plant in October 1983. Zimmer's total sunk costs equaled approximately $1.8 billion; Cincinnati's share amounted to $716 million or almost 90 percent of the utility's 1982 net worth.

The Cherokee and Zimmer cancellations are two examples of the recent substantial reduction in the commitment to nuclear power by U.S. electric utilities. Since 1972, over 120 nuclear units have been canceled by electric utilities; over $15 billion had been spent on these units. These cancellations represented over one-half of the total previously ordered nuclear generating capacity, and no new nuclear units have been ordered since 1977.

The decision to cancel a nuclear power plant is important in terms of its impact on the affected utility's future cash flows. Even in a favorable regulatory environment, the affected utility rarely will be allowed a sunk cost recovery system that results in a zero net present value. As a result, the initial announcement of a nuclear power plant cancellation should be treated by stock market investors as a negative informational event. Furthermore, larger price declines should be associated with cancellations involving larger sunk costs.

In addition, make sure to read these articles:

  • Will Oddball Advertising Boost Your Business?
  • Will Oddball Advertising Boost Your Business? By NICOLE GULL "To tout CI Host, his Texas-based Web-hosting company, Christopher Faulkner paid a man $7,000 to ......
  • Nuclear energy.
  • In March 1998, U.S. nuclear generating units produced a total of 54 net terawatthours (billion kilowatthours) of electricity, 7 percent higher than in March 1997....
  • Rising above sunk costs
  • HEADNOTE FOCUS ON WHAT'S BEST FOR YOUR COMPANY'S FUTURE. The name is arcane. But if you've ever shelled out major dollars for auto repairs only ......
  • What are sunk costs?
  • This note addresses the ambiguities in contemporary treatments of sunk and fixed costs. Sunk costs of contestable market literature identify cost differences between established firms ......
  • Korean Workers Exposed to Nuclear Power...
  • The Korea Times recently reported that the Korean Ministry of Science and Technology (MOST) revealed this week that the Wolsong Nuclear Power Plant experienced a ......
  • Construction Begins on New Nuclear Power Plant...
  • Pakistani newspaper Kashar News recently reported that construction has begun on the 325-megawatt (MW) Chashma Nuclear Power Plant Unit 2, the country's third nuclear facility....
  • Bulgaria Seeks Bids for New Nuclear Power Plant.
  • AFX News reported last week that Bulgaria's National Electricity Company (NEC) is seeking bids for construction of a proposed $3.2-million nuclear power plant in the ......
  • Small Fire Extinguished at Perry Nuclear...
  • FirstEnergy Corporation recently announced that operators of the Perry Nuclear Power Plant in Perry, OH extinguished a small fire in a fan motor bearing for ......
  • Accenture and Indus to Help Paks Nuclear Power...
  • BUDAPEST, Hungary -- Accenture (NYSE: ACN) and Indus International Inc. (NASDAQ: IINT) have signed a multi-year agreement with Paks Nuclear Power Plant, which generates ......
  • Germany Shuts Down Obrigheim Nuclear Power Plant.
  • Reuters recently reported that a spokesperson for the German state of Baden Wuerttemberg has revealed that Utility EnBW disconnected its 340-megawatt (MW) Obrigheim nuclear power ......
  • Freon Leak Temporarily Shuts Down NJ Nuclear...
  • PSEG Nuclear recently announced that an "unusual event" was declared late last week at its Hope Creek generating station, a 1,049-megawatt nuclear power plant located ......
  • Perry Nuclear Power Plant Refueling...
  • FirstEnergy Corporation subsidiary FirstEnergy Nuclear Operating Company (FENOC) recently announced that additional improvements made during the Perry Nuclear Power Plant's current refueling outage are expected ......
  • An empirical analysis of the impact of asset...
  • INTRODUCTION There has been a significant increase in the frequency and magnitude of asset writedowns(1) in the 1980s and the early 1990s. Grover (1992) reports ......
  • WaterPure International Places First Atmospheric...
  • Replaces Need for Bottled Water DOYLESTOWN, Penn. -- WaterPure International, Inc. (OTCBB:WPUR) announced today that it has placed their atmospheric water generator (AWG) inside one ......