Small Business Resources, Business Advice and Forms from AllBusiness.com

Some bad, some good comes out of Albany.

By Klein, Ruben
Publication: Real Estate Weekly
Date: Wednesday, July 28 1993

For most owners, the recent legislative session in Albany on extension of the rent stabilization laws was, from a short-term view, a waste of time. Because of what it could have accomplished, I might even call it a disaster for the affordable housing industry.

As everyone acknowledges,

the luxury decontrol that was adopted will help only a minuscule part of the private rental housing business.

It's my sense that owners of private low- and middle-income apartment properties are stunned by adoption of a four-year extension without their getting significant relief as a tradeoff.

Nobody I know expected the rent stabilization laws to be extended for more than the usual two years. A representative of an afford-able housing owner-group was so angry he compared the impact of the rent-law extension on his members to owners receiving a four-year sentence on top of 50 years already served.

However, on a happier note, we should acknowledge the significance of the State Senate refusing to extend the stabilization laws without at least some changes. The Senate used its ability to stymie the entire renewal process as a fulcrum for change. I believe this was the first time that this has happened, and I commend the Senate for putting this tactic to good use by launching the start of what I hope will be a decontrol process, however long it takes.

I am sorry to say that while reading newspaper reports about the rent-law extension negotiations (the media presented them as cliff-hangers) I got a definite impression that far too many of our state elected officials don't understand the plight of the owners of affordable, private rental apartment properties and the terrible impact that controls have had and are continuing to have on this valuable asset.

Fortunately, we were able to hold off an anticipated assault on the Major Capital Improvement program. Angelo Aponte, commissioner of the Division of Housing and Community Renewal, had announced a desire to extend the pay-back period for MCIs to 72 months, up from 40 months. It didn't happen. The 40-month period holds and any MCI increase will remain a permanent part of the rent.

Probably the most positive achievement that came out of the legislative battle on extension of rent stabilization was the tacit recognition by the legislature in passing luxury decontrol that the rent laws are a subsidy. The industry has been maintaining this for decades. In addition, the new rent law relates rent-regulatory protection to income. This is a "first" for this.

It's too bad that so many of our state legislators hold the view that even families earning $240,000 a year still need the subsidy of rent regulatory protection.

Under the decontrol bills passed by the legislature:

* For families earning $250,000 a year for two consecutive years and paying $2,000 a month in rent as of Oct. 1 rent law protection will be taken away from them when their leases expire and when their incomes are verified by the State Department of Finance and Taxation acting for the Division of Housing and Community Renewal. The DHCR presumably will then issue a decontrol order.

* For families paying $2,000 a month in apartment rent - rent law protection will be taken away from these apartments, but only after the current tenants vacate them

Considering.that owner groups were asking for the decontrol of apartments occupied by families earning $100,000 a year and paying closer to $750 a month, the above changes are relatively minor. That leaves many of us wondering what really went on in Albany. Did the legislators pay much attention to the issue of why the floor was $250,000 and not, say, $245,000? Or why a tenant earning $250,000 or more and paying only $1,000 a month should continue to be protected by the rent laws, while a tenant earning the same amount and paying a much higher rental would lose the protection?

There isn't any logic to the way these-decontrol provisions of the new law were structured, 'and nobody I've heard is suggesting that the luxury decontrol changes will encourage owners to rebuild the city's affordable housing stock. The new regulations will only affect some 12,000 apartments in New York, or less than 2 percent of the apartments in New York City and its suburbs.

But, still, tenant advocates, fearing the $250,000 floor might be lowered in the future, attacked the changes. The fact that tenant groups were able to marshal sizeable forces in opposition to the changes even though they really had nothing immediate to lose from luxury decontrol, highlights the fantastic grip the rent laws have on us. These groups bussed their members by the thousands to Albany.

I haven't meant to appear to be overly pessimistic, but as a practical political matter it must be admitted that general vacancy decontrol -- however logical - is not yet in the cards. Initially, the State Senate took what seemed to be a very strong position on this, and then backed away.

The BRAB, Ruben Klein president, is the largest owner-industry organization in the Bronx. BRAB represents more than a thousand owners of 2,000 buildings housing more than 150,000 residents.

In addition, make sure to read these articles:

  • New rent laws seen as victory for owners.
  • Recently, both the New York State legislature enacted new legislation and the New York City Council passed a new measure which provide for deregulation of ......
  • Court upholds RTC right to evict rent-controlled tenants.
  • In theory, the Resolution Trust Corporation can now begin repudiating leases and evicting rent-stabilized and rent-controlled occupants of the cooperative and condominium units that it ......
  • Preserving vacancy decontrol.
  • The Rent Stabilization Association, representing owners and managing agents of over one million apartments in New York City, continues to play a vital leadership role ......
  • In rem properties keeping the city in hock.
  • What other city than New York City has been forced to own and try to operate so much multi-family rental property? What other city than ......
  • For the good of New York, end rent regulation.
  • I would like to tell you that rent regulation will end because it is un-American, or because it is unconstitutional (see the Bill of Rights), ......
  • Permanent rent laws? Enough is enough.
  • Enough is enough. After a half century of destructive rent regulations, it appears that the best the New York State Assembly can do is to ......
  • Housing heroines.
  • Gov. George Pataki recognized Assemblywoman Carmen E. Arroyo and Margarita Grasing, executive director of the Hispanic Brotherhood Inc. of Rockville Centre, with the Champions of ......
  • Guidelines hearings continue in Westchester.
  • The Westchester rent guidelines board met last week to hear presentations by owners and tenants with regard to rents in 18 municipalities that have adopted ......
  • NYARM: education for today's managers.
  • NYARM: Education for today's managers Trade associations offer several reasons for joining, be it social, educational or for the networking opportunities. Whether you're looking for ......
  • Wisconsin State Senate OKs Franchise Bill
  • A state franchising bill in Wisconsin has been overwhelmingly approved by the state Senate, which sent the measure back to the Assembly for its consent ......
  • Division of Housing and Community Renewal.
  • The October Problem: The Division of Housing and Community Renewal has proposed changes to the administrative code that could solve the current October renewal problem....
  • What happens when an apartment owner lowers rent?
  • Many New York City apartment rents have legally risen so high under stabilization that they are above what the market will bear. So owners are ......
  • Met Life reaches accord with DHCR on windows.
  • Met Life reaches accord with DHCR on windows While New York State handed Metropolitan Life an onerous ruling concerning its extensive window replacement major capital ......
  • Incentive bills die in Albany.
  • Three revisions of New York City property incentive programs died in the final hours of the New York State Senate session. The Industrial and Commercial ......