Small Business Resources, Business Advice and Forms from AllBusiness.com
 

Retirement Planning: Should I Pay for My Kids' College?

Monday, September 17 2007



One of my readers recently asked me this question:

Should I use some of my retirement funds to help my kids with their schooling? Many of my friends plan to pay for their children's educations. Is it an obligation for parents?
This is a question that is getting a lot of play right now. It is natural for parents to want to help, but it may not be fiscally sound to raid the retirement funds to help your children pay for college. Even if you aren't taking the money out of your retirement account, even putting less in so that you pay for your kids' college may be a bad idea.

Why do parents feel they have to pay for college?

Of course you want to give your children a good start in life. But paying for everything may not be the best way. Teaching children valuable money skills such as investing, saving and managing a bank account will benefit them more in the long run than taking on their tuition costs. But in today's world, we are made to think that we should be handing everything to our kids, lest we be painted with the "bad parent" brush. (Miki Saxon, at Leadership Turn, addresses the "children as special" myth that can be as damaging.) However, it is not bad parenting to raise your children to take care of themselves.

Secure your retirement account first

It is not wrong to secure your retirement account before setting money aside for your kids' college. Contribute the maximum allowable to your retirement accounts, and then see what is left over for a 529 college savings plan or some other type of account. You should make your retirement funds your first priority. It has been famously said, by a number of gurus, "You can get loans for college. There are no loans for retirement."

My parents made it clear to me that I was in charge of my tuition. They said they could afford a certain amount to help me with room and board, but beyond that, I was on my own. I got scholarships, a part-time job on campus and some student loans. The key was that my parents began teaching me about money before I was 12, and always made clear exactly how much help I would receive. They gave me ample time to prepare my own path. And I am grateful that I know how to manage my own money, rather than cluelessly relying on my parents.

Start planning now for your retirement

A great Forbes piece on retirement planning v. kids' college points this out:
"Many young parents think linearly," says Duane Meek, senior vice president for retirement plans at Nationwide Financial Services in Columbus, Ohio. "Get a job, move up, buy a house, start a family, educate the children--and then think about retirement. But once they've taken care of the kids, there's not enough time to benefit from the compounding of earnings over 30 or more years."
This means that NOW is the time to start retirement planning. You should open a retirement account as soon as you can, and contribute what you can. You can save for your kids' college after you have taken care of your own future.

Tags: , , , ,
, ,

Latest Comments in  posts

The reader's question raised two issues. One is the advisability of using retirement funds to pay for college for one's kids; the other is the obligation of parents to pay for college. I can see that using retirement funds to pay for college is foolhardy. If finances are that tight shelling out for college will only make things worse. But as for the larger question of helping with school expenses -- these treatises on the character of one generation versus another can be so facile. Would we really base our financial relationship with our children on the results of a "standardized narcissistic personality inventory"? Besides, isn't the accusation of selfishness from the Baby Boom generation rather like the pot calling the kettle black?
By: Mathilde on 9/17/07 at 4:33 PM
Point taken about inter-generational spats. Although I find that it is exactly the baby-boom generation that is by and large falling into the trap of paying for everything for their children. My baby-boomer parents didn't (they couldn't afford to pay for all five of us), and my own Gen Y or whatever I am self can't see paying for my son's college completely. Maybe I'm the selfish one...
By: Miranda Marquit on 9/19/07 at 2:05 PM
You must sign-in or sign-up to comment on this post.

Franchising Expert
mleonard_80
Ask Mark Leonard, Our
Franchising Expert,
Your Question
Small Business Expert
rlesonsky_80
Ask Rieva Lesonsky, Our
Small Business Expert,
Your Question
B2B Sales Expert
jkonrath_80
Ask Jill Konrath, Our
B2B Sales Expert,
Your Question
Sales Expert
krosen_80
Ask Keith Rosen, Our
Sales Expert,
Your Question
Business Travel Expert
krosen_80
Ask Ken Walker, Our
Business Travel Expert,
Your Question
Finance Expert
sthacker_80
Ask Sam Thacker, Our
Finance Expert,
Your Question
Invention Expert
Ask Stephen Key, Our
Expert on Licensing Your
Invention, a Question