Small Business Resources, Business Advice and Forms from AllBusiness.com

Fat chance for sanity about obesity

By Scarry, Donald M
Publication: NJBIZ
Date: Monday, August 4 2003

Hula Hoops. Pet rocks. Long hair and granny glasses. This country has seen a lot of fads and the latest one is to blame obesity on food companies.

No one knows what obesity costs in terms of health care, but just under $100 billion a year seems to be the consensus. That's roughly 10% of the

national bill for health care. And that 10% provides an occasion for legislators-who have little to do besides introducing new bills and taxes-to spring into action.

Clearly obesity is a serious issue that's growing in severity and importance. According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 13% of U.S. adolescents are overweight or obese and children between the ages of six and 11 have the fastest growing rate of obesity in the country. Two years ago, the U.S. Surgeon General issued a "Call to Action to Prevent and Decrease Overweight and Obesity."

Now comes the New Jersey Legislature to remedy this state's share of the problem. As former State Senator John Lynch liked to say, quoting Mark Twain, "No man's life, liberty, or property are safe while the Legislature is in session."

When lawmakers addressed smoking, they acted with a vengeance. For starters, New Jersey banned smoking everywhere it could be banned and then raised cigarette taxes to the highest level of any state in the country.

But legislators have little power to deal with our eating habits other than to tax foods or repeat your mother's warning that "eat too much and you'll get fat." Years ago, with tongue planted firmly in cheek, I proposed a "fat tax" based on calories, fat content and other aspects of the food we eat. I may yet see such a tax, since passing this kind of legislation allows legislators to claim they're doing something while giving them more money to spend.

The Philadelphia Inquirer recently reported that 179 bills or resolutions dealing with obesity have been introduced in state legislatures this year, up from the mere 72 that were proposed last year. Two of those 179 bills are before the New Jersey Legislature.

One, A3592, introduced by Herb Conaway, a Democratic Assemblyman from Delran, would require managed-care plans to treat adult obesity, which is probably a good idea. This bill was introduced on May 15 and has not come up in committee.

The other measure, A3534, sponsored by Democratic Assemblywoman Loretta Weinberg of Teaneck, would create the New Jersey Obesity Prevention Task Force. Weinberg previously sponsored a bill that would have banned smoking on school buses when no students were on board.

Weinberg's latest measure declares that "[i]t is in the interest of the public health for the State to establish a New Jersey Obesity Prevention Task Force to develop recommendations for specific actionable measures to support and enhance obesity prevention among New Jersey residents, particularly among children and adolescents." I italicized "actionable measures" because the phrase shows that this lawmaker really does want action.

Weinberg's task force would no doubt launch a multimedia, interactive, holistic information program with the "voluntary" cooperation of the food industry to warn consumers that, "if you eat too much, you'll get fat!"

SIDEBAR

"No man's life, liberty, or property ore safe while the Legislature is in session."

IMAGE PHOTOGRAPH 1AUTHOR_AFFILIATION

Donald M. Scarry is the founder of New Jersey Economics, a Mt. Laurel research firm. E-mail to scarry@njeconomics.org.

In addition, make sure to read these articles:

  • Attacking the Smoking Ban
  • HEADNOTE STATEHOUSE HEADNOTE Opponents want lighting up prohibited at casinos too A statewide ban on smoking in restaurants and other commercial establishments will have to ......
  • Jersey Lawmakers Seek Tax on Internet Cigarettes
  • Excise taxes expected to reach $790 million this year.
  • It's Still Tough to Beat The Marlboro Man
  • On the third floor of the Middlesex County Administration Building in New Brunswick, a visitor will find the mass tort law division which houses files ......
  • The role nutrition plays
  • The role of food and nutrition in preventing and treating disease has been poorly recognized outside the healthcare industry. But the U.S. Surgeon General's Report ......
  • Radon emerges as a state issue
  • The U.S. Surgeon General issued a national health advisory in 2005 urging Americans to test their homes to find out how much radon might he ......
  • Radon emerges as a state issue.
  • The U.S. Surgeon General issued a national health advisory in 2005 urging Americans to test their homes to find out how much radon might be ......
  • Juvent Brings Its Vibrations To the U.S. Market
  • For more than two decades the scientists behind Juvent, a medical-device maker in Somerset, have been developing a nondrug treatment for osteoporosis. The disease, marked ......
  • Government health diet ignores beverages.
  • In 1988, the U.S. Surgeon General issued a report recommending what leading nutrients were believed as the most healthful die -- not for weight loss ......
  • Fat-food nation
  • Ours may be the only culture in which a significant number of people think they're nourishing themselves with fruit and fiber when they eat a ......
  • Shelton named to Hall of Fame.
  • Robert M. Shelton, FHFMA, CAE, past president of HFMA, has been posthumously inducted into Modern Healthcare magazine's Hall of Fame. The program honors men and ......
  • The Internist: Health Policy in Practice.
  • More and more physicians see environmentalism as a natural extension of their commitment to the health of their patients. Practicing physicians who also practice environmental ......
  • A CHECKLIST OF DIETARY & FLUID NEEDS: NUTRITION & EXERCISE
  • A recent report by the U.S. Surgeon General revealed Americans can improve their quality of life and lifespan, and reduce risk of disease by increasing ......
  • Why psychologists should have prescriptive authority.
  • The debate about whether psychologists should be able to prescribe psychoactive medication has often been labeled a "turf' issue--psychologists wanting to expand their scope of ......