Small Business Resources, Business Advice and Forms from AllBusiness.com
 

Dealing with draft dodgers: Automatic production of drafts of expert witness reports

By Romines, Franklin D II
Publication: The Review of Litigation
Date: Tuesday, April 1 2003
IMAGE TABLE 1IMAGE TABLE 2

I. INTRODUCTION

As defense counsel in a slip-and-fall case, you are deposing the plaintiff's key expert witness,

his physician. You are suspicious of the doctor's testimony from the start, because what began fifteen months ago as complaints of shoulder problems by the plaintiff have now developed into low back pain and leg difficulties. Plaintiffs counsel cancelled the doctor's prior deposition, claiming that the doctor was not prepared to testify because of gaps in his medical file. In a new report, served seven days before the second scheduled deposition, the doctor now opines that the plaintiff's lumbar disc problems were caused by the accident at issue.

At the deposition you discover something interesting in the file: a draft of the opinion letter that is not on the doctor's letterhead. Interestingly, it mirrors the doctor's final report aside from one discrepancy. That discrepancy is the inclusion of the following note at the top of the draft report: "PLEASE HAVE RETYPED ON YOUR OWN STATIONARY. THANK YOU."1

In addition, make sure to read these articles:

  • How to Conduct Discovery for Your Court Case
  • Discovery is the pre-trial phase in a court case during which each party can use certain methods to obtain information and facts and gather evidence ......
  • Finding the Right Small Business Lawyer
  • Your lawyer will be a trusted ally, so make sure you do your due diligence when choosing one.
  • Attorney Fees Provisions in Contracts
  • An attorney fee clause is a provision that states that the prevailing party in any dispute arising under the agreement shall be awarded his or ......
  • Rebuttal: Experts ethics testimony
  • According to Giles Scofield, ethicists can provide expert testimony in descriptive ethics and metaethics, but not normative ethics. Lawrence Schneiderman appears to disagree with this ......
  • Transportation Expert Witness Council
  • Membership: 487 individuals Dues: $20 Chair: Joseph S. Champagne, Champagne Associates PC The Transportation Expert Witness Council supported and sponsored events at both the ITE ......
  • Expert-witness defect claim not enough
  • In March 2001, Donald Shaffer, a service engineer for Amada Engineering and Service Inc., was injured while servicing a press brake at Newco Inc.'s plant ......
  • Insurer's Misappropriation of...
  • Ellwein v. Hartford Accident and Indemnity Co., 15 P.3d 640 (Wash. 2001) (enbanc) Nancy Ellwein was seriously injured in a 1989 auto accident, suffering permanent ......
  • Expert Bioethics Testimony
  • The question of whether the normative testimony of ethics experts should be admissible under the rules of evidence has been the subject of much debate....
  • An expert witness can make or break a case.
  • EXECUTIVE SUMMARY * THE CPA EXPERT WITNESS MUST CHOOSE an approach in the pretrial planning phase that will develop and integrate facts and legal theories ......
  • An expert witness as seen by an expert witness
  • HEADNOTE Professor Adam Neville is a civil engineering consultant, arbitrator and vice-president of the Royal Academy of Engineering. He was Concrete Society President for 1974-75, ......
  • Expert witness would have recommended that...
  • AIRLINE INDUSTRY INFORMATION-(C)1997-2003 M2 COMMUNICATIONS LTD During a hearing into the China Airlines crash in August 1999 an expert witness has said that he would ......
  • Of two wrongs that make a right: Two paradoxes of...
  • This essay offers a new rationale for the standard of proof requirements in civil trials. The civil proof doctrine, as traditionally understood, presents two economic ......
  • Testimony from an expert witness.
  • An objective view ensures that your strategy doesn't fail. With some regularity I am asked to be an expert witness in court cases involving food ......
  • HOW TO BE AN Expert Witness
  • HEADNOTE Here's what you should know about the litigation process to serve as a successful technical witness. IMAGE PHOTOGRAPH 1 MANYENGINEERSANDSCIENTISTSGET the opportunity to serve ......
  • Good lawyering and bad role models: The role of...
  • INTRODUCTION Defining the role of the attorney has become problematic in recent years. Attorneys now frequently play the part of advocate, counselor, or even mediator....