Small Business Resources, Business Advice and Forms from AllBusiness.com
 

How to write better employee evaluations.

By Ramsey, Robert D.
Publication: Supervision
Date: Monday, June 1 1998

In the vast majority of factories, shops and offices across the country today, the most dreaded and despised supervisory function of all is the periodic written employee evaluation. Supervisors don't like to write them because it puts them on the spot. Workers don't like to receive them because

they think they are artificial and unfair. In fact, no one in the organization completely trusts them. Nevertheless, writing periodic job reviews continues to be a basic responsibility for most managers, supervisors and foremen. Formal written performance appraisals are universally disliked; but remain universal anyway.

To make matters even worse, these much-maligned job reviews continue to carry enormous clout in organizations of all sizes. No matter how unscientific or untrustworthy they may be, written evaluations still determine wage increases, bonus amounts, promotion possibilities and, even job security, in a large proportion of businesses and industries nationwide.

Entire lives and careers can be shaped or shattered by a single written evaluation. It's no wonder formal performance appraisals are feared equally by those who give them and those who get them.

Among human resources professionals, it is generally agreed supervisors everywhere need to do a much better job of evaluating their employees. It has to begin by identifying the trouble with the way many job reviews are handled today.

What's Wrong With Written Evaluations?

About the only thing supervisors and subordinates agree on regarding written job assessments is they don't work. The most common complaints include the following:

* Supervisory personnel rarely receive training on how to write effective evaluations. Somehow, it is assumed anyone worthy of becoming a manager or supervisor has the innate ability to appraise the work of others accurately and to reflect their assessments in writing. This is one of the business world's more fallacious assumptions.

Analyzing a worker's overall performance requires skills which have to be learned. Likewise, writing clear and concise evaluations is an art which needs to be perfected over time through carefully guided practice. Many supervisors today write ineffective evaluations simply because they don't know how to do it any better.

* Some managers (particularly those new to the supervisory ranks) don't have the breadth of experience necessary to judge and compare the performance of a diverse group of workers. To evaluate properly, supervisors need to compare the performances of others with something more than just their own personal work experience. It takes time and exposure to build reliable standards of behavior and productivity.

In addition, make sure to read these articles:

  • How to supervise in the middle of a merger.
  • Most of business and corporate America is caught up in megamerger mania. From banks and airlines to computer companies and hospitals, businesses of all kinds ......
  • How to supervise home workers.
  • It's not a fad. It's not a glitch. It's not even an emerging trend any more. It's reality and it's now a fixture. Home workers ......
  • 101 ways to be a better supervisor tomorrow.
  • Most managers and supervisors want to get better at what they do. Like most employees, they want to be the best they can be at ......
  • Insourcing is the latest wrinkle in outsourcing...
  • Everybody's doing it—outsourcing, that is. Automotive and electronics manufacturers have been doing it for years. Software vendors and IT providers are getting into it big ......
  • Love your competition.
  • Love thy enemy. That's what the scriptures tell us. For some reason, however, many managers and supervisors seem to think the ancient biblical admonition doesn't ......
  • handling hazards in the workplace.
  • Unless you supervise in a munitions plant, a fireworks factory or a nuclear waste facility, you probably consider your workplace relatively safe and hazard-free. Think ......
  • How to enjoy your job more (10 steps to greater...
  • What keeps millions of Americans awake worrying at night, gives countless men and a growing number of women ulcers each year, is one of the ......
  • So you've been promoted or changed jobs. Now what?
  • If you have a dog who chases cars, did you ever stop to wonder what the family pooch would do if it actually caught one?...
  • Maximizing the Value of 360-Degree Feedback: A...
  • Walter Tornow, Manuel London, and CCL Associates, ISBN: 0787909580 San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 1998 Reviewer: Stephen B. Kincaid, Ph.D. Sperduto & Associates, Inc. Atlanta, Georgia Recent ......
  • 101 ways to be a better supervisor tomorrow.
  • Most managers and supervisors want to get better at what they do. Like most employees, they want to be the best they can be at ......
  • How to supervise in the middle of a merger.
  • Most of business and corporate America is caught up in megamerger mania. From banks and airlines to computer companies and hospitals, businesses of all kinds ......
  • How to keep key workers.
  • Keeping key employees is the top issue for CEOs of emerging growth businesses according to a 1998 survey conducted by the Minnesota Council of Growing ......
  • Managing noise in the workplace.
  • You can't smell it. You can't see it. You can't taste or feel it. Yet environmental observers label it a hazardous pollutant in the workplace....
  • How to become a more family-friendly supervisor.
  • Family matters matter more than ever before in the workplace. More women and men alike are now trying to balance career demands with the responsibilities ......
  • How to leave a job.
  • Changing jobs is a common occurrence in today's economy. Thousands of people do it every day. Sooner or later, you probably will, too. Supervisors don't ......